It's Christmas Day at the Nelson's, a joyous occasion marked by one glitch - the catcher's mitt Ozzie ordered for Rick never arrived. That evening, Ozzie and Rick drive to another family named Nelson thinking that the package might have been delivered by mistake. The package isn't there, either, but Ozzie and his son are struck by how the family, a single mom and three young children, and received so little at Christmas compared to their own relative prosperity. Ozzie organizes the neighbors, and with David playing Santa Claus, treat the other Nelson family to a second Christmas Eve. Later that evening, a package holding Rick's catcher's mitt mysteriously reappears under the Christmas tree.